Call us on 05991 73300 | Text 085 8766 529 | Email us at refunds@redoak.ie

What Revenue doesn’t want you to know about underpayments

Written by Administrator on July 22, 2014

Revenue UnderpaymentsIt’s becoming more and more common these days for people to receive notice from Revenue that they have an underpayment and owe Revenue extra tax money. This prompts endless questions…

  • What does that mean?
  • How did this happen?
  • Doesn’t my employer look after this?
  • How am I going to pay them back?

…none of which are answered by Revenue and so, through fear and frustration, many people start paying back their unpaid taxes.

Stop right there!

Before you pay any additional money to Revenue, you should always get your taxes checked by an expert.

All too often, I see cases where at first it appears a person will owe money to Revenue, but when I dig a little further, there are errors on Revenue’s record or tax credits that the customer hasn’t claimed. Revenue don’t tell you about these – all they do is balance the information they have. So if it is wrong, or you haven’t notified them of any changes, then the P21 balancing statement is not going to be correct.

Here’s an example I had recently:

A 68 year old man contacted Red Oak after receiving a notice from Revenue that he had underpaid taxes to the sum of €1,991 in 2012. After reviewing his application and the details Revenue held, I also discovered smaller underpayments in 2009 and 2010.

The client had a dependent wife who was on social welfare and as all payments were going to him, this has triggered the underpayments in Revenue’s system.

After doing a full review of the couple’s taxes, I noticed that their total income was within the range that would grant the husband a partial exemption from income tax due to the fact that he was over 65 years. By applying this exemption, the underpayments for 2009, 2010 and 2012 were cleared and I was able to secure a refund of over €2,000 for the client.

It pays to get a second opinion

The truth is, in many instances, the underpayment has been caused by some sort of error or there are tax credits that haven’t been applied which will clear any unpaid taxes. So, it’s always worth getting a second opinion to make sure that Revenue have calculated your taxes correctly.

Unfortunately, there are still a few instances where the underpayments are correct and in those cases, we can help advise of the best course of action to help you get your taxes in order.

To get an expert second opinion on your taxes, contact us today.

Written by Sarah Bambrick

Sarah Bambrick - Tax AgentI’ve worked at Red Oak for almost a year and have discovered the hidden thrill of finding Revenue’s mistakes. I studied Law at DCU, so I have a keen eye for detail. As a Tax Agent, my job is to ensure that all my customers get everything they are entitled to.

Posted Under: Income Tax, Paye Tax, Refund Examples, Social Welfare, Tax Refunds

10 replies to “What Revenue doesn’t want you to know about underpayments

  1. Peter Plaice

    Hi – I have received a P21 balancing statement from revenue that states I underpaid €4,528.62. How much would you charge to review this for me and advise if it is correct?

    Thanks

    Peter

    Reply

  2. shane mathews

    Hi
    I asked for a p21 and got a nasty surprise today that my spouse and I under paid by nearly €5k. This is approx €90 extra a week one of us got last year but we didn’t. I am calling to the Tax office tomorrow. Have you any advice?
    Thanks

    Reply

    1. Post Author Administrator

      Hi Shane
      Thanks for your message.
      This could be due to any number of reasons. We can look at this to determine if the underpayment is correct, however this service is a flat fee of €120 per tax year.
      If you would like us to look at this for you, please email us at refunds@redoaktaxrefunds.ie
      Regards
      Nerilie

      Reply

  3. Mary

    I work 16.25hrs a week school term time. I have received tax back in wages after breaks . However now my husband has received his p21 statement saying we owe tax of 1,800. They have come up with this by adding my earnings with his and deducting his tax paid and our joint tax credits , is this right

    Reply

    1. Post Author Administrator

      It may be correct Mary – you have to be so careful in transferring tax credits during the year, as your husband might get the extra tax credits, but it may not have been removed from yours.
      We generally recommend not moving tax credits during the year.
      However, you should get that checked , they may have incorrectly removed tax credits either.

      Reply

  4. Lora

    If you have underpaid Tax as a reault of the revenue office sending a new employer an incorrect tax cert for you is there any recourse? Both employee and employer completed the required steps but the tax office issued an incorrect cert to the new employer?

    Reply

    1. Ray Byrne

      Hi Lora,

      Thanks for getting in touch. If the underpayment is correct then Revenue are entitled to collect it back. Generally Revenue’s view is that it is up to the tax payer to ensure that their taxes are in order. Without knowing the specifics it all depends on what they say but if it is correct they will collect it from you as you would have been due to pay that tax at the time.

      All the best,
      Ray

      Reply

  5. Jacinta

    Hi guys. I’ve changed jobs in August this year. I was emergency taxed for the first 2 weeks, updated revenue with my new employer number, was put on week 1 tax. Then when they received my p45 they put me on normal tax basic. I’m now been taxed a whopper amount that I simply can’t afford. My new employer are telling me I’ve underpaid taxes and I’m being taxed accordingly now, but as far as I was aware I was being taxed correctly or so I thought.. is there anything I can do in this situation?

    Reply

    1. Ray Byrne

      Hi Jacinta,

      Thanks for getting in touch. Your employer should be taxing you correctly then if they have your amended tax credit certificate and your P45 from your previous employment. Your employer is the one who deducts the tax so would be best to check with them what information they are using.

      All the best,
      Ray

      Reply

Leave a Reply to Ray Byrne Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Please answer the question (For anti-spam purposes) *